Check what's new on our other blogs:

The Romanian Liberals (a study in disaster)

Je t’aime moi non plus… Romania has two nominally Liberal parties that are permanently at loggerheads. The smaller one (ALDE) is part of the present ruling coalition, together with the Socialists (PSD), while the other (National Liberal Party, PNL) is lurking in the opposition, bracing itself for the European elections, for which it still has to present a credible list.

The (in the opposition) PNL is led by the capricious and unpredictable Ludovic Orban (brother of the first Romanian EU Commissioner, Leonard Orban, and bearing no relation with Hungary’s Viktor Orbán). To top it, these PNL “Liberals” have compromised themselves in 2012 by forming a coalition with the same PSD “Socialists” in order to overthrow the elected president from that time Traian Basescu. They were shielded and cajoled then by the former chief of the Liberals in the EU Parliament, Graham Watson, who intervened on their behalf by attacking the… EPP:  “For the leaders of the European People’s Party to criticise political developments in Romania almost beggars belief. Was it not the same EPP who backed Berlusconi when he rode roughshod over the rules of Italy’s politics? Is it not the same EPP now supporting Borissov and Saakashvili playing fast and loose with the rules of democracy in their countries? And did the European People’s Party’s MEPs not give Viktor Orban a five minute standing ovation in Strasbourg despite his anti constitutional antics?”, asked Graham Watson then, in the summer of 2012,

The then PNL party leader, Crin Antonescu, who badly wanted to take Basescu’s place, finally managed to become interim president, for a few painful days, applauded in Brussels by ALDE, and to the furor of the EPP, who was protecting Basescu.

Two years later, in 2014, Antonescu’s PNL deftly switched sides and, albeit Liberal in name, was accepted as a full member by the very EPP it had vilipended earlier. The EPP-backed PNL is now in the opposition in Romania, they intend to stay in the EPP and have as direct enemy the other “Liberal” party, cleverly called ALDE, who have ganged together with the eternal Socialists and who are now quietly dismantling what has remained of the Romanian justice system. Less patient than his predecessor Graham Watson, the ALDE chief at the European level, Guy Verhofstadt, keeps threatening to expel the Romanian ALDE from the transnational party. The PNL (previously in ALDE) are applauding.

All these contortions and ideological crawling were to be expected, but why on earth did the EPP, who still keeps Basescu’s party, now called PMP (The People’s Movement Party), as a member, accept PNL, the very foes who have tried to overthrow Basescu and helped dent and durably enfeeble the Romanian democracy?

Not only that, but the PNL has all backing of the EPP that it savagely attacked only a few years ago, as Romanian Socialist MEPs now bitterly deplore.

Well, rules were lax then for entering the EPP, which has since become a vast political dumping ground, functioning by the logic of numbers. Led for decades by the late Wilfried Martens, the EPP has for a long time been accepting anyone, Berlusconi’s Forza Italia for instance, or Ivo Sanader’s Croatian HDZ, provided they claimed to be right-leaning. The Hungarian Viktor Orban has also managed to persuade the EPP to accept his Fidesz as a member, although he, at the time, had just villainously left the Liberal International, of which he had been vice chairman since 1992. To be accepted, Viktor Orban didn’t even need to display much Christian, or even democratic credentials.

So it appears that many have been cavorting from the Liberals to the EPP, who accepted them with open arms, following only the logic of the numbers.

No wonder then, as we already pointed out, that there is nothing ideological in the disparate groupings in Romania ahead of the May European elections.

All this to say that the existence of two fighting supposedly “Liberal” parties in Romania, PNL (now in the EPP) and ALDE does not mean anything in ideological, political, or even cultural terms. Both have allied themselves with the Socialists (read: Populists) at some time, and practically all the major figures of both groups have always worked for the state and never ran a successful business, as Liberals should do.

It is even rumored that some of the younger Liberals still live with their parents.

Be the first to comment on "The Romanian Liberals (a study in disaster)"

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


The project was co-financed by the European Union in the frame of the European Parliament's grant programme in the field of communication. The European Parliament was not involved in its preparation and is, in no case, responsible for or bound by the information or opinions expressed in the context of this project. In accordance with applicable law, the authors, interviewed people, publishers or programme broadcasters are solely responsible. The European Parliament can also not be held liable for direct or indirect damage that may result from the implementation of the project.